Survey: 70% of Muslims say U.S. should legalize polygamy

Muslims are piggybacking on the gay marriage caravan. This story, and survey results, from the Muslim Brotherhood Linked newspaper out of Maryland:

…nearly 70 percent said they believe that the U.S. should legalize polygamy…42 percent of those surveyed said they were either in, or knew others in polygamous marriages within the local Muslim community. Thirty nine percent said they would engage in a polygamous marriage if it were legal in the United States.

Polygamy: Tis The Season?

Many argue that polygamy is an exception to the free exercise of religion because known cases of polygamous marriages of young girls. This cast a shadow on the practice and many ignorantly equated it with pedophilia. Recent attacks on the Prophet Muhammad also equated his marriage to Aisha, who was nine at the time, as an act of pedophilia. In cases where religious practices are deemed harmful to individuals or to the public, the free exercise of religion no longer applies.

While Islam itself does not condone acts of homosexuality and though the mainstream Muslim community remains largely uninvolved with polygamy in the United States, there are a minority who still engage in the practice though largely in secrecy for fear of retribution. While some masajids require legal proof of marriage prior to granting an Islamic marriage, some Imams’ like Baltimore city’s Hassan Amin believe polygamy to be a god-given right that cannot be denied to those who are willing and able despite the potential legal ramifications.

“I don’t have any problem with that because it’s Deen. I’m doing it for religion,” said Amin who admits to performing polygamous marriages.

Amin, a sociology instructor at Sojourner-Douglass College of Baltimore regularly discusses polygamy in his classroom. Not only does he note its religious significance but the benefits it can have in American society, particularly in areas like Baltimore city where the poverty rate is high and many women find themselves on the welfare roll.

“We have in the world more women than men and if a man has the ability to take care of more than one women he should be able to do that,” said Amin. “As far as legalization, I think they should…We should strive to have it legalized because Allah has already legalized it.”

While Amin feels strongly about the good polygamy can do for the community, others feel as though the issue of polygamy is one that should remain in a historical context.

“The family institution in the U.S, whether it is Muslim or non-Muslim, is very delicate. The idea of having many partners and many, many children who are neglected or whose needs will not be met fully or even who will compete for gains is not a healthy one in this society. This society is full of much corruption without the addition of internal corruption. It is allowed in Islam, I do not argue this fact. Our Prophet allowed this but in today’s time we do not have the pure intentions and love for one another as they did in the past,” said one individual in a recent survey on polygamy conducted by The Muslim Link.

Approximately 42 percent of those surveyed said they were either in, or knew others in polygamous marriages within the local Muslim community. Thirty nine percent said they would engage in a polygamous marriage if it were legal in the United States.

One woman, who wished to remain anonymous, having been part of a polygamous relationship for fourteen years expressed her support for the institution arguing its ability to solve many moral ailments that plague today’s society.

“I believe the government should legalize polygyny because it is lawful in Islaam. It would enable all the wives to have the same legal status…As a matter of fact, I have discussed the issue with many non-Muslim women as well. The majority of them say that if polygyny was conducted the way that it is supposed to be according to the Qur’aan and Sunnah, they would have no problem with it. It is much better than committing adultery, fornication and having illegitimate children,” she wrote in response to the survey.

Born and raised in Christian family, she married a non-Muslim man at the age of twenty-two. One year later both her and her husband converted to Islam. They lived in a mongomous marriage for nine years before her husband approached her about marrying a second wife.

“When my husband told me that he wanted to marry another woman we discussed the issue and the three of us met and had discussions as well.  There was a public nikah and waleemah at our masjid, and the whole community, including our children and [I], attended,” she said.

Though the second marriage ended in divorce after fourteen years, it ended on good terms.

Although those who said they would engage in polygamy if it were legal are the minority, nearly 70 percent said they believe that the U.S. should legalize polygamy now that it is beginning to legalize gay marriage.

As for opinions on whether or not Imams, like Amin should be allowed to conduct polygamous marriages despite polygamy being illegal in the United States, the results were almost split right down the middle with approximately 54 percent against the idea.

Polygamy is arguably not the most popular practice in the United States and even within religious communities where polygamy had an undeniable historical significance. However, the First Amendment was meant to protect even the least popular of practices on the basis that though they may not appeal to the general public, their existence and the rights therein should and will always be protected under constitutional law.

Still, some feel as though the Muslim community should be focused on fighting to protect the rights that they do have rather than rallying behind ones that could send the wrong message.

“We also need to consider that legalizing an issue makes it “okay” in a lot of people’s minds. If polygamy were okay, people who don’t understand it’s conditions may enter into such relationships that could prove very unhealthy, Muslim and non-Muslim alike. The issue of polygamy is not fully understood by our own Muslim community for it to be taken to the U.S. government. I really think we should focus on fighting for the rights we currently are guaranteed under law but are not always granted,” wrote one young woman.

For example?

As for the American Muslim community and the practice of polygamy, Amin believes it is the responsibility of the Muslim leadership to represent its benefits both religiously and socially.

“As an Imam I have a responsibility to put Islam out there in all its beauty and glory. Even if I stand alone in doing this, Islam has be be out there and more imams have to stand up for Islam,” he said.

Though he doesn’t believe it is a necessary practice for everyone and notes that only those able to practice polygamy within the rules laid out in Islamic teaching should consider engaging in it, Amin feels its a reality that the American Muslim community should not hide or feel embarrassed by.

Causing Fitna sent us this audio/video of Muslims discussing polygamy in the U.S., where it is probably more rampant than anyone will admit:

16 Responses

  1. Islam is not a religion. It is a political system, and violent. Nazism is closest.

    In this cult, pedophilia is common. Young boy love is acceptable, and you dress them up for fun before the rape. It is not pedophilia if you marry them for an hour. Honor killings, or child killing is really a form of suicide in Britain. Killing your wife by stoning is an old tradition. Genital mutilation keeps them at home.

    This stuff makes me sick. This is from Satan, and must be fought by education.

  2. Are all Muslim IMORIAL ? in AMERICA we call that Adultery.So Just keep your TRASHY LIFE STYLE TO YOUR SELF oR BETTER STILL GO BACK WHERE YOU CAN be more comfortable living like commoners.
    YOU SOUND LIKE YOU HAVE THE MIND OF ANIAMIALS,

  3. Who was it told me muslim women dress in berkas because they have respect for their bodies? Your life style really don’t match with that statement.
    I can’t see where muslim men respect wemon at all.
    That is SAD,You don’t belong in America.if a man EVER showed me disrespect or,layed a hand on me ,there would be i less man in the world,Enough Said.

  4. There is an excellent book titled ‘The Polotics of American Religious Identity’ by a lawyer converted to education named Kathleen Flake. It outlines concisely how the issue was tackled when the issue was mormon plural marriage. Its the method used to understand not the mormons at issue here.

  5. In Europe it”s the same; also here in Canada. And like the US we also have the “spin off” cult, inspired by islam ( Mormons) And yes, we have here in British Columbia, the delightful settlement of Bountiful, where dirty old men have several wives and rape little girls. For some reason most people don”t seem to know the con-man who invented the Mormon “religion” did so while languishing in prison–and he patterned it on ISLAM. mohammed would have been proud of Joseph Smith. In the meantime, I despair of so many people in western countries caving in to the constant demands of these 7th. century nerds; A bright 10 yr. old child could see through what they are doing–but not our leaders, oh no!!

  6. Please forgive me for being off-topic, but I have some potentially significant news that will be of interest to readers: Tommy Robinson is to leave the English Defence League for electoral politics. It will shortly be announced that he is to join the British Freedom Party: http://durotrigan.blogspot.com/2011/11/tommy-robinson-to-leave-edl-for-british.html

  7. Like I said, they didn’t come here to assimilate, they came to colonize and take what we have built without doing the work. They hate our values and lifestyle and wish, in the long run, to convert the country to a muslim country. Polygamy is the beginning and sharia is the end.

  8. Send the Mooslems to Penn State;they like.VARIETY.

  9. [...] in principle to limit the Shari'ah to some aspects of human life and leave out others." Survey: 70% of Muslims say U.S. should legalize polygamy   MuslimLink.com via creeping As Legal Marriage Is Redefined, Some Muslim Call for Decriminalizing [...]

  10. U.S. should BAN Islam. It is our mortal enemy.

  11. [...] in principle to limit the Shari’ah to some aspects of human life and leave out others.” Survey: 70% of Muslims say U.S. should legalize polygamy MuslimLink.com via creeping As Legal Marriage Is Redefined, Some Muslim Call for Decriminalizing [...]

  12. PLEASE if you want to know the TRUTH about Obama do your self a favor go to ,The Patriots News then type in,
    Potitical Qualifications
    Evidence Broadens
    Obamas Natural Born Conspiracy

    Then if that is not enough info,go to.
    Canada Free Press
    The Theory is Now a Conspiracy and Facts Don’t Lie
    Now if you arent American enough to take time to look this up ,then you aren’t showing much concern what is happening to America.

  13. I am thinking of starting a new religion; The tenents would be goverened by the American Constitution. And it would be everyones religious duty to execute a muslim daily.

Your comments & your IP address are your legal problem, not ours.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 35,085 other followers

%d bloggers like this: