Idaho: “anti-Sharia” bill passes, with just 2 ‘no’ votes

What politician in America would be opposed to banning sharia law in the U.S.?  Source: House State Affairs backs anti-Sharia bill after long hearing, with just 2 ‘no’ votes | The Spokesman-Review

After more than two hours of testimony both for and against the bill, the House State Affairs Committee has voted to approve Rep. Eric Redman’s anti-Sharia law bill, with just two dissenting votes. The two dissenters were Reps. Elaine Smith, D-Pocatello, and Dustin Manwaring, R-Pocatello; Rep. Paulette Jordan, D-Plummer, wasn’t present, nor was her substitute who’s filled in for her earlier this week, as she submitted her resignation from the Legislature today. All other committee members supported Redman’s bill, which he calls “American Law for American Courts.”

The bill follows model legislation developed by the American Public Policy Alliance, a group headed by Louisiana attorney Stephen Gele that promotes the concept to states, and has gotten it passed in several. A 2010 Oklahoma constitutional amendment forbidding that state’s courts from considering Sharia in decisions was overturned in federal court in 2013. Redman said his bill could affect other types of foreign laws as well.

Redman, R-Athol, shared stories of atrocities in other countries he attributed to Sharia law; Muslim citizens of Idaho told the committee that’s not how they practice their religion.

His bill, HB 419, would declare void any court ruling that relies “in whole or in part on any foreign law” that doesn’t match U.S. or Idaho protections for due process, freedom of religion, speech, press, privacy or marriage. The bill doesn’t specifically mention Islamic Sharia law, but it was the focus of both Redman’s comments and of numerous questions from several members of the committee.

After all the testimony, Redman told the panel, “One comment I heard was that I could possibly be a bigot. Well let me tell you something: My middle daughter is a teacher from Olympia, Wash., is married to a refugee from Cambodia and he is a Muslim. This is not about the religion.”

Rep. Smith said, “I just want to say that Idaho courts are already protecting our freedoms and laws and I feel this bill is not necessary, so I’ll be voting no.”

The committee vote moves HB 419 to the full House for debate and a vote.

At the same time the hearing was going, Gov. Butch Otter was taking questions from Idaho reporters at an annual Idaho Press Club event. Asked about the anti-Sharia law bill, he said, “I guess I can’t appreciate the concern. The courts are going to enforce our laws. The courts are not going to enforce some other country’s laws.”

He noted that in his nearly 12 years as governor, he’s appointed numerous judges, including district judges throughout the state, three of the four judges on the Idaho Court of Appeals, and three-fifths of the Idaho Supreme Court. Otter said he’s always questioned judicial candidates about “the enforcement of our laws,” and is confident that’s where Idaho judges are focused.

This is the third year that Redman has proposed the bill. In 2016, it was sent by the same committee to the full House for amendments, after it drew heavy flak from Idaho parents of children adopted from overseas, who said it would threaten the process by which such adoptions win legal approval. The bill was amended, but then never came up for a final vote. Last year’s version didn’t get a hearing.

You may ask yourself why is the topic of sharia law even an issue in Idaho. Well, Idaho has become a Muslim refugee dumping ground and Muslims are wreaking havoc in Idaho. Read some of the archives of Muslim refugees raping young girls, forcing colleges to change mascots, and the billionaire yogurt maker who uses Muslim refugees as cheap labor.

10 thoughts on “Idaho: “anti-Sharia” bill passes, with just 2 ‘no’ votes

  1. Congrats to Idaho !! There are many more States that seek to get Sharia (and only Sharia Law) approved. We, the American People, have only one Law of the Land and that is the Constitution! No foreigners coming into our Country should never be allowed to impose their so-called ‘law & religion’ in the United States. All States should NOT ever be permitted to even be considered in the State’s Legislature! Sharia law does not promote freedom nor support anyone’s rights, especially women!!

    • Well said Ms Wade; islam is permitted here, but sharia will not! Bravo Mr Redman.
      To Rep Smith: If Idaho courts are protecting your freedoms, then you should have supported this bill!
      As for Mr Manwaring, I hope he has a plausible explanation.
      I visited Boise 30 years ago and loved it. I hear that now it is turning into a sh-thole, thanks to Chobani

  2. Now Idaho can join California in their effort to leave the rest of America. I just don’t understand how anyone could be o.k. with sharia law. They will make a good pair.

    • Oh Chaz… It’s an ANTI-Sharia Bill that passed..

      Good for Idahoans!

      There are adults there!


      …My comment from deep in the bowels of Minnesota-stan.. Trust me, this is good for Idaho..

  3. Good for Idahoans!

    There are adults there!


    …My comment from deep in the bowels of Minnesota-stan.. Trust me, this is good for Idaho..

    • You are absolutely correct that the bill doesn’t identify sharia law-good point! Parents should encourage their children: anything spoken about islam or sharia should be brought home.
      If we give them an inch; they want to take 10 miles! My exaggeration is no bs!
      LOOK AT THE LIST ON THE RIGHT OF THIS SITE! They are a clear threat to America- their ideology is neither compatible with or welcome here by Americans. But American politicians are ramming them into America along with the DOJ against our wishes. We already have two in Congress, and more in the pipeline. This was the same pattern with Hitler in Germany.

If sharia law continues spreading, you'll have less and less freedom of speech - so speak while you can!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s